After Dilworth Park’s success, what about City Hall courtyard?

June 20, 2017 - garden totes

Three years ago, a dowdy, underused metropolitan piazza in front of Philadelphia City Hall underwent a Cinderella-style transformation that has finished it one of a livelier open spaces in town. Its private manager, a Center City District, now maintains Dilworth Park with such fastidiousness it literally sparkles in a sun.

The same, unfortunately, can't be pronounced about a stepsister spaces around City Hall, that are still in a city’s care. In a retreat chronicle of a angel tale, a courtyard, portal walkways, and sidewalks around John McArthur’s great, French-inspired chateau are a ones in tatters.

Renovating those outside areas would cost millions, though a city will dress adult a yard temporarily this summer with a pop-up drink garden, interjection to a place-making extend from Southwest Airlines. The income will compensate for new seating, umbrellas, and a opening stage, as good as an desirous news of events being curated by a city’s enlightenment staff. All a activity promises to concentration open courtesy on one of a city’s many thrilling, if neglected, outside spaces. But after a second pop-up subsequent summer, a income runs out.

Then what?

Landscape pattern organisation Sikora Wells Appel skeleton to use H2O totes and rain-catching umbrellas for a Culture on Tap pop-up drink garden in Philadelphia’s City Hall yard this summer.

It should come as no warn to anyone who has been following a expansion of downtown Philadelphia that a Center City District’s president, Paul Levy, is already study a problem. Over a final decade, his classification has resuscitated 4 downtown parks and will shortly supplement a Reading Viaduct to a portfolio. Although a initial proviso of a Rail Park isn’t approaching to be finished until January, Levy told me he has begun a review with a tiny organisation of city officials and consultants about what could be a CCD’s subsequent project: a courtyard.


At slightest half a century has upheld given a courtyard’s final vital renovation, and a wear and rip shows. The aspect is a mismatch of brick, concrete, and asphalt. The paint on a in-ground compass, a favorite with residents and tourists alike, is fading. The courtyard’s 4 SEPTA entrances are hardly used, nonetheless they clunk adult a space. Now that Dilworth is all shined up, a contrariety between a dual adjacent plazas couldn’t be some-more extreme.

City Hall courtyard, transport entrances people flitting through. Monday, May 22, 2017. STEVEN M. FALK / Staff Photographer

Levy is a master during revitalizing such problem open spaces, and his organisation could simply take on a yard renovation. But given a stress of a space — a mystic heart of a city — a review needs to be taken to a wider group. We should be articulate about a courtyard’s destiny together as a city, maybe in a space itself, over beers.

That’s not how it was finished with Dilworth, that occupies an equally distinguished position in Philadelphia’s earthy and mental landscape. There was comparatively small open contention before a Nutter administration outsourced a front doorway to City Hall to a CCD. The designs were presented to a open during all a common forums, of course. But open display is not a same as open engagement.

One effect is that there are critical open issues that were never worked out before a CCD became Dilworth’s steward. There is no clarity about either public demonstrations are authorised in a park. We’ve never resolved how we feel about renting out this critical retard of open genuine estate for private events.

As Philadelphia and other cities increasingly come to rest on private managers to manage and account their parks, these issues keep entrance up. We’re saying it right now during Franklin Square, that is being rented out in a evenings for 5 weeks to a money-making Chinese Lantern Festival. In contrast, Levy said, Dilworth is off-limits to a open only 5 percent of a time. That doesn’t sound like much, though it’s a homogeneous of 18 days a year. Is that an excusable trade-off for being means to run by a enchanting dash fountain or movement underneath a stars?

A park worker closes an open territory in a blockade along 6th Street around Franklin Square during 4:30 p.m. in credentials for a Chinese Lantern Festival. a sections are left open during a day. TOM GRALISH / Staff Photographer

For now, a city has no skeleton to outsource a yard to a CCD. Indeed, Deputy Planning Commissioner Alan Urek told me he believes a city “should contend jurisdiction.” At a same time, he pronounced that “there have to be artistic ways of removing some-more resources” to urge a courtyard.

Raising income is Levy’s strength. After receiving grants from Poor Richard’s Charitable Trust, the substructure run by Lisa Roberts and David Seltzer, and a William Penn Foundation, he hired WRT to rise a pattern devise for improving a courtyard. Although their ideas are still rudimentary, Levy offering to uncover me a preview of their progress.

This digest illustrates a offer for City Hall courtyard, designed by WRT for a Center City District. Credit: WRT

Their offer calls for clearing a yard of a confusion to emanate a clean, stretchable aspect that could be used for a accumulation of activities, identical to Dilworth’s multipurpose slab expanse. The courtyard’s dated, over-scaled planting beds would be ripped out. So would during slightest dual of a 4 SEPTA transport entrances. Removing those elements would boost a serviceable space from 22,000 to 39,000 retard feet. WRT’s offer offering no visualisation about a predestine of a compass. But it’s tough to suppose a restoration that didn’t urge on that dear element, that outlines a geographic core of William Penn’s strange grid.

All a outside spaces around City Hall are manly with meaning, yet, astonishingly, there has never been a master devise for a whole garb — a north and south aprons, a portal walkways, as good as a yard and Dilworth. We keep adding things, like a Octavius Catto sculpture now being commissioned on a south apron, but meditative about what competence come next.

A new sculpture of Octavius Catto is underneath wraps on a south apron of City Hall.

The purpose of a yard has developed given City Hall non-stop in 1901, Levy noted. It was creatively designed for deliveries, quite of prisoners. The vans would expostulate adult to a dual towers on a south side, where sortie ports led to holding cells and courtrooms. That use finished during some point, substantially around a time a Criminal Justice Center non-stop in 1995. The Nutter Administration ramped adult a programming of a yard by installing cafeteria tables and bringing in food trucks.

Although a yard has nothing of a sculptural luxury of City Hall’s exterior, it is a absolute space, a room really, whose sides are shaped by a pattern of a dull towers and well-spoken walls. Because it is cut off from a sound of a city, it functions like a library reading room. It creates sense, as Levy suggested, to pattern it as a still refuge, an choice to Dilworth’s nonstop activity.

This summer’s pop-up promises to broach both moods. During a day, it will offer a untrustworthy oasis with spontaneous seating and umbrellas designed by branding and graphics dilettante Exit and landscape pattern organisation Sikora Wells Appel, pronounced Kelly Lee, a city’s arch informative officer. At night, a furnishings can be reassembled to form a opening space. Riffing on a Parks on Tap program, a city skeleton to call it Culture on Tap. Special programs will be offering on Thursday evenings. “We wish to make it a place where all Philadelphians feel comfortable,” she said.

Once a summer is over, a same perspective should expostulate a long-term formulation for a courtyard.






Thanks for your continued support…

We recently asked we to support a journalism. The response, in a word, is heartening. You have speedy us in a goal — to yield peculiarity news and watchdog journalism. Some of we have even followed by with subscriptions, that is generally gratifying. Our purpose as an independent, fact-based news classification has never been clearer. And a guarantee to we is that we will always essay to yield indispensable broadcasting to a community. Subscriptions are accessible for home smoothness of a imitation book and for a digital reproduction ocular on your mobile device or computer. Subscriptions start as low as 25¢ per day.
We’re grateful for your support in each way.



Philly.com comments are dictated to be civil, accessible conversations. Please provide other participants with honour and in a approach that we would wish to be treated. You are obliged for what we say. And please, stay on topic. If we see an disgusting post, greatfully news it to us regulating a “Report Abuse” option.

Please note that comments are monitored by Philly.com staff. We haven a right during all times to mislay any information or materials that are unlawful, threatening, abusive, libelous, defamatory, obscene, vulgar, pornographic, profane, faulty or differently objectionable. Personal attacks, generally on other participants, are not permitted. We haven a right to henceforth retard any user who violates these terms and conditions.

Additionally comments that are long, have mixed divide breaks, embody code, or embody hyperlinks might not be posted.

Load comments


Please capacitate JavaScript to perspective a comments powered by Disqus.

More totes ...

› tags: garden totes /